Lev Semyonovich Vygotsky (1896--1934)
29 Jun 2023 11:43
Soviet psychologist and prominent "pre-cognitivist". His work focused on the development of cognitive skills, especially skills of self-control, and how these were supported ("mediated") by external tools, above all the culturally-provided tools of language and social interaction. He was particularly interested in the ways people "internalize" such tools, learning to do without such scaffolding, though it's necessary for the acquisition of the skill. (He went so far as to speculate that all cognitive abilities originated as internalizations of social interactions. Whether he meant this ontogenetically or phylogenetically, or in some sense both, I can't tell, and in any case it seems very unconvincing to me.) One way of thinking about what he was doing (grossly anarchonistic but useful) is that he was interested in how orgnaisms with limited computational ability can effectively expand their information-processing powers by interacting with structured environments --- think of how, in formal language theory, attaching a stack to a finite-state machine lets it generate context-free languages, not just regular languages. Another anachronistic framing is that he was interested in collective cognition. Some modern Vygotskyans believe their socio-cultural approach is an alternative to the more usual, computational approach to cognition. This has never made any sense to me, more or less for the reasons Frawley lays out in his book.
This was inteded as a self-consciously Marxist, but nonetheless objective and scientific, psychological theory, emphasizing the role of history and social relations, as well as the functional, adaptive character of thought. Comparisons to American pragmatism and to Piaget are common-place. Comparisons to positivism, in the mode of Ernst Mach or the Logical Positivists less common but equally apt. (I imagine that Vygotsky and Otto Neurath would've had a lot to say to each other, if Vygotsky could've gotten over Neurath's rather unorthodox approach to Marxism.) I should probably say something here about the Soviet academico-political decisions which led Vygotskyism to be officially suppressed in favor of Pavlovian reflex-psychology, forcing his best students into neuroscience, but I don't feel up to it today.
- Recommended, primary:
- L. S. Vygotsky
- Thought and Language
- Mind in Society: The Development of Higher Psychological Processes [Mini-review]
- Recommended, secondary:
- William Frawley, Vygotsky and Cognitive Science: Language and the Unification of the Social and Computational Mind
- A. R. Luria [Most prominent of Vygotsky's disciples, best known
for his work on neuropsychology.]
- The Making of Mind: A Personal Account of Soviet Psychology
- Cognitive Development: Its Social and Cultural Foundations [Remarks]
- Recommended, tertiary:
- Michael Tomasello, Becoming Human: A Theory of Ontogeny [An explicitly neo-Vygotskian theory, which tries to take due account of the need to evolve the capacities to engage in social interactions and to internalize them]
- To read:
- Laura E. Berk, Awakening Children's Minds: How Parents and Teachers Can Make a Difference [Vygotskian psychology for parents; why hasn't anyone written this before?]
- Cambridge Companion to Vygotsky
- Harry Daniels (ed.), An Introduction to Vygotsky
- Yuriy A. Karpov, The Neo-Vygotskian Approach to Child Development
- Alex Kozulin, Vygotsky's Psychology: A Biography of Ideas
- Alex Kozulin, Boris Gindis, Vladimir S. Ageyev and Suzanne M. Miller, Vygotsky's Educational Theory in Cultural Context
- Ronald Miller, Vygotsky in Perspective
- Susan Pass, Parallel Paths to Constructivism: Jean Piaget and Lev Vygotsky
- Annalisa Sannino (ed.), Learning and Expanding with Activity Theory
- Daniel L. Silver, Tom M. Mitchell, "The Roles of Symbols in Neural-based AI: They are Not What You Think!", arxiv:2304.13626
- Anastasia Tryphon et al., Piaget-Vygotsky: The Social Genesis of Thought
- Jaan Valsiner and Rene van der Veer, The Social Mind: Construction of the Idea
- James V. Wertsch
- Mind as Action
- Vygotsky and the Social Formation of Mind