Books to Read While the Algae Grow in Your Fur, May 2007
- C. J. Sansom, Dissolution
- A hunchbacked lawyer shuts down an English monastery for Thomas Cromwell
and Henry VIII; soul-searching and homicide ensue. There is an amusing, but
mericfully passing, allusion to The Name of the
Rose.
- Yuji
Ijiri and Herbert
Simon, Skew
Distributions and the Sizes of Business Firms
- One of the depressing aspects of
the power laws project, for me,
was that it proded me into finally reading this collection of papers by Herbert
Simon and collaborators. By now, everyone interested in the subject is (or
should be) aware that
the "preferential
attachment" mechanism for generating power law networks is a re-discovery
of
a 1955
result by Simon (building
on earlier
work
by Yule),
showing that distributions with power-law tails are produced by certain kinds
of multiplicative growth processes obeying a weak form
of Gibrat's law.
What is more depressing is to see: how Simon was able to modify his basic model
to produce other log-normals, cut-off power laws, and other heavy-tailed
distributions; how he could handle correlated growth; how he developed the
connection to Bose-Einstein statistics (no I am not exaggerating); etc.
Strictly speaking, Simon generally works with what he calls a Yule
distribution, and some people call a Yule-Simon,
which approximates a power law in its tail; his growth models don't seem to
produce pure power laws, but neither do the data support pure power laws.
- The really depressing aspect is that Simon realized the thing to
do wasn't just to draw straight lines, or even particular kinds of curves, on
log-log plots, but to see where the data disagreed with the model's predictions
and to use that to learn about the mechanisms at work, especially by
checking their other predictions and assumptions. Shockingly little
of this has been done over the last thirty years.
- I used to think that when I described complex systems as a series of
footnotes to Herbert Simon, I was joking, but now I wonder...
- Warren Ellis, Chris
Sprouse and Karl Story, Ocean
- A deliberate hybrid of 2010
(a space station named "Clarke's Walk", no less!) and Revelation
Space, though with fewer squicks than the latter.
- Warren Ellis and Ben
Templesmith, Fell, vol. 1, Feral City
- Collection of the first eight issues of the comic book; each issue was
deliberately designed to work as a self-contained story, and they do, but they
also nicely integrate into a cohesive tale, about unhappy homicide detective
Richard Fell trying to maintain order in
the "feral city" of
Snowtown. (I wonder if that name, and the bit about the well in the first
issue/chapter, are a reference to John Snow and the Broad Street pump?) The
protagonist is transferred to Snowtown, under an unspecified cloud, at the
beginning of the story; we get to discover it along with him. Readers of
Ellis's weblog will remember that many of the crimes here — especially
the most grusome and implausible-sounding ones — are culled from actual
news reports.
- Homicide seems like a definite influence; there's something of
Frank Pembleton
(pre-stroke) in Fell. This does not seem to help explain why Richard Nixon is
repeatedly sighted wandering around Snowtown in a nun's habit, however.
- Andrea Camilleri, The
Smell of the Night
- Ponzi schemes — not called that — gone sour. Thanks to "Uncle Jan" for
the gift.
- John Mueller, Overblown:
How Politicians and the Terrorism Industry Inflate National Security Threats,
and Why We Believe Them
- Brief comment: Word.
- Longer comments: Terrorism, Mueller says, is not an existential
threat to our civilization or our societies or polities, which are very, very
strong. A much worse threat to our freedoms is in fact over-reaction
to terrorism, and the (ridiculous, cowardly) impulse to advocate
authoritarianism and the abandonment of the rule of law in the name of
"security". The readiness of so many supposedly serious people in positions of
authority to advocate this is far more worrying to Mueller, and I must say to
me, than is terrorism itself. If, in the incredibly implausible worst-case
scenario, someone manages to nuke the Capitol, the White House and the
Pentagon, that would be an incredible disaster and a tragedy. One should,
obviously, take reasonable steps to prevent that. (Let me add that many of my
family works around there, so I'm not one to treat this lightly.) But I
utterly fail to see how that would be in any way helped by abandoning the
Constitution, much less how that would threaten the survival of the United
States of America...
- There isn't enough, for me, on the political economy of the situation here.
Mueller hints at, but doesn't really explore, a notion which sometimes seems
only too plausible to me, that we have created a permanent class of
defense/intelligence/security contractors, linked in very hard-to-unravel ways
to military and political figures, all of whom look for threats to justify
themselves (Mr. Cunningham and friends beyond only a particularly flagrant
example), creating a mess which it is hard for the ordinary political
process to fix.
- Diarmaid MacCulloch, The
Reformation: A History
- Vast, global history of how Latin Christendom came to tear itself apart
into so many distinct, mutually-intolerant chunks, going from the late 1400s
through about 1700. It's well-written, and does a very good job of explaining
just enough of the theological issues at stake — and I use the word
advisedly — to make the disputes comprehensible. One nice feature is the
sustained attention to the reformations in eastern Europe (Poland-Lithuania,
Hungary, Transylvania...), part of a broader sense on MacCulloch's part of
it-could-have-gone-otherwise. Another running theme — often no more than a
sub-text — is that almost all the major participants on all sides were
viciously intolerant theocrats, who would have regarded freedom of conscience,
if it had been explained to them, as a flat invitation to heresy, and a policy
promoting it as the civil power failing in its God-given duties, probably with
Satanic inspiration. Modern ideals of liberty grew out of the locales where
the different strands of Reformation and Counter-Reformation fought each other
to draws, and so failed — places like, for a while, some of the
eastern European commonwealths, and more permanently and momentously, Amsterdam
and London. The modern world was born from the 17th century abandonment of the
ideal of "Christendom", in which all full members of society belong to the same
Church, whose writ is enforced by the State which it in turn legitimates.
- (MacCulloch is too good a historian to waste time on silly analogies that
say that "what Islam really needs is a Reformation", but I'm not a historian so
I'll bite. If you take this seriously, then what you are prescribing is that
multiple transnational ideological movements compete violently for the
authority to reward virtue and punish vice, leading to an endless series of
civil and regional wars. The Reformation was not the
Enlightenment.)
Books to Read While the
Algae Grow in Your Fur
Posted at May 31, 2007 23:59 | permanent link