Myths, and Mythologies as Meta-Myths
26 Aug 2024 11:32
First order myths: As stories. Empirical evidence for archetypes (apparently all negative; see Kirk's Myth); for other "deep" meanings and interpretations. Cross-cultural patterns. Historical patterns.
Mythologies as meta-myths: One of my long-nourished, pet, half-crank notions is that the late 19th and early 20th centuries were, in fact, a golden age of mythopoesis; it's just that the mythopoets were all academically trained intellectuals, writing for a newly-arrived mass audience that wasn't just literate but also schooled. So the myths took the form of theories and abstractions, rather than conventional narratives about people & gods. (Exhibit A: Freud.) So the characteristic form of modern mythology is a theoretical system where the abstract concepts of the theory are actually so loose, woolly, and close to every-day thought and feeling that one can't validly derive strong conclusions using them, or actually explain anything with them, but they seem to lend themselves to certain sorts of conclusions and explanation. Yet their pliability means that people who want to derive different conclusions from the same theory can easily do so --- just as narrative myths could easily be inflected to point to all kinds of morals or justify all manner of behavior and institutions.
Recursively, one important area for this sort of modern, theoretical myth-building is, in fact, general theories of myths, in "mythology" as an intellectual subject. These mythologies have in turn been taken up by writers and other artists and been used in some ways rather like myths themselves. (Exhibit B, because of its tremendous cultural reach, is how George Lucas used Joseph Campbell's ideas about myths in Star Wars, but it's not hard to find much more elevated examples, e.g., the influence of Frazier's The Golden Bough in the first half of the 20th century.) This suggests that people who consciously tried to create narrative modern myths were simply behind the times.
(I say "since the late 19th century" becuase the first such figure I'm thinking of as I write this is Max Müller. But it wouldn't surprise me to find general-theories-of-myths, and their artistic use, at any point from Romanticism onwards. [I am not counting the Enlightment conviction that myths are an amalgam of ignorance, cognitive illusions and deliberately manipulative priestcraft as a general theory of the kind I mean here, though it is of course a very good explanation of a lot of myths.])
If I ever try to seriously write up this unholy chimera of Gellner, Flynn and Sperber, I've gone emeritus and should be gently dosed with dried frog pills.
See also Joseph Campbell; Ernst Cassirer; Conspiracy Theories; Mircea Eliade; Sigmund Freud; Carl Jung; Millenarianism; Narrative Communities; Religion; Role-Playing Games; Structuralism; Superstition; Universal Signs, Images and Symbols
- Recommended:
- Don Cameron Allen, Mysteriously Meant: The Rediscovery of Pagan Symbolism and Allegorical Interpretation in the Renaissance
- Elizabeth Wayland Barber and Paul T. Barber, When They Severed Earth from Sky: How the Human Mind Shapes Myth
- Mircea Eliade
- Carlo Ginzburg, Clues, Myths and the Historical Method [Some critical remarks under Historiography.]
- G. Kirk, Myth: Its Meaning and Function in Ancient and Other Cultures
- Bronislaw Malinowski, Magic, Science and Religion
- Dan Sperber
- Rethinking Symbolism
- On Anthropological Knowledge
- Ian Strenski, Four Theories of Myth in Twentieth-Century History: Cassirer, Eliade, Levi-Strauss and Malinowski
- Not altogether recommended:
- Joseph Fontenrose, Python: A Study of Delphic Myth and Its Origins
- To read:
- Stefan Arvidsson, Aryan Idols: Indo-European Mythology as Ideology and Science
- Stephen T. Asma, On Monsters: An Unnatural History of Our Worst Fears [Review in Bookslut]
- Philip C. Ball, The Modern Myths: Adventures in the Machinery of the Popular Imagination [This is almost 180 degrees from my half-crank notion, but I like Ball's writing so I'm very eager to read this]
- Hans Blumenberg, Work on Myth
- Chiara Bottici, A Philosophy of Political Myth
- Luc Brisson, How Philosophers Saved Myths: Allegorical Interpretation and Classical Mythology
- Malcolm Bull, The Mirror of the Gods: How Renaissance Artists Rediscovered the Pagan Gods
- Claude Calame, Myth and History in Ancient Greece: The Symbolic Creation of a Colony
- Robert Ellwood, The Politics of Myth: A Study of C. G. Jung, Mircea Eliade, and Joseph Campbell
- Carlo Ginzburg and Bruce Lincoln, Old Thiess, a Livonian Werewolf: A Classic Case in Comparative Perspective
- Greta Hawes, Pausanias in the World of Greek Myth ["Pausanias gives us the clearest glimpse of Greek myth as a living, local tradition... "]
- Ronald Hutton, Queens of the Wild: Pagan Goddesses in Christian Europe: An Investigation
- Sarah Iles Johnston, The Story of Myth
- Leszek Kolakowski, The Presence of Myth
- Malinowski and the Work of Myth: Selected and Introduced by Ivan Strenski
- Dean A. Miller, The Epic Hero
- Kathryn A. Morgan, Myth and Philosophy from the Presocratics to Plato
- Daniel Ogden, The Dragon in the West: From Ancient Myth to Modern Legend
- Jaan Puhvel, Comparative Mythology
- Timothy Taylor, The Buried Soul: How Humans Invented Death
- Stith Thompson
- The Folktale
- Motif-Index of Folk-Literature: A Classification of Narrative Elements in Folktales, Ballads, Myths, Fables, Mediaeval Romances, Exempla, Fabliaux
- John B. Vickery, The Literary Impact of "The Golden Bough"
- P. Vidal-Naquet
- Marina Warner, Six Myths of Our Time: Little Angels, Little Monsters, Beautiful Beasts, and More
- Calvert Watkins, How to Kill a Dragon: Aspects of Indo-European Poetics
- John J. White, Mythology in the Modern Novel: A Study of Prefigurative Techniques
- George S. Williamson, The Longing for Myth in Germany: Culture, Religion, and Politics from Romanticism to Nietzsche
- E. J. Michael Witzel, The Origins of the World's Mythologies [Color me skeptical]