Books to Read While the Algae Grow in Your Fur, February 2020
Attention
conservation notice: I have no taste, and no qualifications to opine
about epidemiology, sociology, or the history of ideas. Also, I'm writing
book reviews during faculty meetings downtime.
- István Z. Kiss, Joel C. Miller and Péter L. Simon, Mathematics of Epidemics on Networks: From Exact to Approximate Models
- My attempt at a summary grew to
a full-length
review (which needs a better title).
- Erik Olin Wright, How to Be an Anticapitalist in the Twenty-First Century
- This is Wright's last book; it continues a long and (unironically) proud
tradition of socialists re-writing the Manifesto: start by saying
why capitalism sucks, while admitting some of its virtues; then explain how it
can be bettered; identify the existing social force(s) which will replace it;
and talk about how those forces will undertake the revolution. Wright says
sound things about how capitalism molds people into selfish jerks (or crushes
them), is undemocratic and (for most) unfree, and offends basic notions of
fairness. (He sensibly refrains from asserting that capitalism either causes
or requires racism, sexism, imperialism, etc., which is at the very least a
highly debatable generalization, though of course racist and sexist capitalists
can be expected to exploit workers in racist and sexist ways on top of
everything else.) He then sketches what he'd like to see instead, which is a
market economy with lots of public provision, some collective ownership, and a
lot of worker and consumer cooperatives. Fantasies of central planning
are, rightly, not part of his
socialist vision. (He does not touch on the delicate problem of how to
coordinate the democratic decisions of the members of a cooperative with the
democratic decisions of the wider socialist commonwealth when the two disagree
[e.g., about whether or not to shut down an oil company], or how to delineate
the right scale for the cooperatives
[is the oil company one cooperative, or does each rig, refinery and gas station become its own cooperative?].)
He also delineates different ways of attacking or at least trying to replace
capitalism, ranging from frontal assaults by violent revolution to separatist
utopian communities to temporary carnivals of defiance to quietly trying to
build alternative institutions that can grow to take over the larger capitalist
ecosystem, a sort of vision of socialism as algal bloom. (That is not his
image.) The end of the book looks at what would be required for a "collective
actor" to try to effect such a transformation --- and there it ends, with a
promise that he was just about to say how the trick would be turned.
- We will never get to hear Wright's thoughts about how to solve that
last riddle, because he died while the book was still incomplete, and what
we have here was polished to publication, but not exactly completed, by
friends and disciples. This is a fitting tribute to a scholar of real
distinction, who made his reputation by combining sound* sociology
with unorthodox, "analytical" Marxism that wasn't afraid to actually think,
and who tried to remain connected to real-life struggles for
a better world. §
- *: More waspishly, no worse, methodologically, than the rest of post-1960s American sociology.
- Jane Langton, The Memorial Hall Murder, Natural Enemy, Good and Dead, Murder at the Gardner
- Classic mysteries from the early 1980s, where the very particular settings,
and often specific works of literature or art associated with them, are just as
important as the murders. I read all these as a boy, but return to them now
with delight, and perhaps more appreciation for their non-murder-mystery
aspects. (For instance, Good and Dead is also a fine novel about
the decline of "mainline" Protestantism, which rather passed me by as a
teenager.) --- Subsequently in the
series. §
- Kwame Anthony Appiah, Lines of Descent: W. E. B. Du Bois and the Emergence of Identity
- A fine study of what Du Bois took from German thinkers of the 18th and
19th centuries, especially from German Romanticism and from the "professorial
socialism" of his teachers in Berlin. It'd probably help to have at least
read The Souls of Black Folk (which Appiah suggests we could gloss
as "the geist of the black volk"), but Appiah's exposition is so skillful that
no deep knowledge of either Du Bois's life and work, or of German thought, is
really needed.
- --- There is a longer story here, which Appiah hints at, at how relevant
early Romantic nationalism (like Herder) remains for contemporary ideas in
fields like "ethnic studies", despite gestures towards acknowledging the
internal heterogeneity and diversity within any such "community". (It's easy
to see how a Herderian would be upset by "cultural appropriation", and hard to
give a coherent account of the offense otherwise
[cf. Richard Thompson Ford, Racial Culture: A Critique].)
Whether this is historical continuity of tradition, and if so whether Du Bois
was one of the channels of transmission, or whether on the contrary it is
parallel re-evolution, would be a fascinating thing to know. §
- Allison Brennan, If I Should Die
- Mind-candy thriller: in which outsiders try to start a legitimate business
in a deeply criminal town in upstate New York, and plot ensues. A bunch of the
soap-opera among the characters presupposing reading the earlier books in the
series. (To be clear, I enjoy the soap opera.)
- Tarquin Hall, The Case of the Reincarnated Client
- Mind-candy mystery, the latest installment in Hall's "Vish Puri" series in
contemporary Delhi. Delightful as always, and I think full enjoyable
without the prior installments. (Read before sectarian riots in Delhi became
topical again.)
- Walter Jon Williams, Quillifer the Knight
- Mind candy fantasy, but high quality mind candy. Quillifer (introduced in
the book of that name) is an opportunistic
social climber with a tragic backstory and a supernatural nemesis in a
formerly-medieval fantasyland undergoing a renaissance. He's charming,
deceptive, clever, realistically concerned with money and finance, and a
convincing mixture of scoundrel and creature of his own conscience. I suspect
that Williams owes some debt to such Renaissance-setting competence-porn as
Hilary Mantel or Dorothy Dunnett, but as always he makes the material fully his
own, so it's not just
"Wolf
Hall with magic".
Books to Read While the Algae Grow in Your Fur;
Pleasures of Detection, Portraits of Crime;
The Progressive Forces;
Commit a Social Science;
Writing for Antiquity;
Scientifiction and Fantastica;
Networks;
Enigmas of Chance;
Complexity
Posted at February 29, 2020 23:59 | permanent link